Nine of us went on the trip and here's how it broke down:
1 walleye
2 white bass
3 smallmouth
1 crappie
1 kentucky
All but two of those were caught on spinnerbaits but we definitely struggled to find anything that would consistently work and we tried EVERYTHING on Friday and Saturday.
I personally tried powerworms, lizards, baby brush hogs, spinnerbaits, crankbaits, finesse worms, wacky rigs, jigs, tubes, Zara Spooks, nightcrawlers. I was really working the 25-35ft range since two other guys on the boat were throwing spinnerbaits almost all day and working them back to the boat from the shore.
I think inexperience was a big factor, though. We'll definitely be back later this year or the same time next year. Had a blast despite not finding the fish.