Fall is the ultimate prime time for muskie fishing. In Fall you get the perfect opportunity to land a true monster. But unfortinalty lake 35 is not an ideal place to expect such success. I am an experienced muskie angler and I have fished muskie waters in Illinois, Iowa, and Minnesota for years, I was never interested in MO muskies since there are not many lakes in MO that have fair amount of muskies in it. From what I have seen Lake 35 has a pretty good muskie habitat a mix of weeds, shallow/deep water, and in some areas submerged timber.
I have spent over 35 hours fishing for muskies last week (5hr-Tue, 4hr-Thur, 14hr-Fri, 12.5hr-Sat) that is more time spent fishing then I did that week at work. I have caught absolutely NOTHING. Sometimes if we don't catch fish we almost every time see or move some fish, but at lake 35 I have not seen a muskie or for that matter moved it. Very little people have been fishing last week, which is a good thing. I have covered every square inch of water those 4 days, I have tried small baits, medium sized baits, large baits, I have tried fishing topwater, shallow, mid-depth, deep, tried 30 different lure types from bucktails, spinnerbaits to shallow invaders, and depth raiders... NOTHING, not even a follow. On Saturday I was able to catch a small largeemouth bass on one of my spinerbaits. The Water temps were averaging 70F on Tue and 68F on Sat.
Something tells me that there is a very small amount of smaller muskies in that lake, which might be the problem why I haven't seen anything. Usually Smaller muskies are boat shy and are confused by our baits that we throw. This is why you always see muskie fisherman land muskies that are 40+ inches most of the time. I have never caught a muskie that was below 36 inches. Unlike their cousins Northern Pike, small pike is not afraid to attack a larger lure but bigger pike is more careful. This is the opposite in muskie fishing, big fish will come to the boat side following the lure but smaller fish will almost 98% turn back.
I will give it a few more trips this year, in a previous forum in 2009 someone from the DNR has posted that during that year in spring when they put out nets they caught 20 fish that were 40-44inch range. Im not sure if those fish are still there since I have seen a lot of people take Bass home and Im sure if they would have hooked on to some muskies that size those would be automatically taken home.
Does anyone know if the DNR is still stocking this lake? Or does anyone know what is the percentage of this fish being taken home for dinner? I would suggest not to take it since it doesn't taste very good and because it has a fair amount of mercury in them, they are better of in the water then they are in the kitchen!!!!
I will post more results once I get out there this week