Brian,
We've met on the river a few times. I doubt you are a meth head, you have too many teeth in your smile on camera. But, your straw man type arguments will not get you out of this argument. Based on the photos and videos, I don't buy that you've NEVER fished a redd or ALWAYS instruct your clients to not fish redds. You catch fish in spawning colors and have video of a dude eating brown trout roe at a pull-out and assert that any fish spewing roe had to be pulled off a redd. It does not jive. Am I criticizing you, if you've ever fished redds? No.
Ness,
Brian does the same, do you have an equal criticism? He clearly admits that a brown was caught that sprayed eggs in a boat, thus, it was "obviously pulled off of a redd." According to him, if you didn't see a redd in the video it wasn't there, so these kids couldn't have been doing what he alleges them to have been doing, because that would be nothing more than an assumption.