This is a really silly argument. A guy made a bad decision, and didn't head the warnings, and got stuck in a bad situation, which apparently you can get fined for. It is a matter of opinion on whether that fine should be enforced, and frankly i don't care either way. I am just happy the guy was ok, and I am glad that Brian at least did what he safely could to help the guy. I have fished with Brian many times, he is one of the most courteous people on the stream, always helping people with technique or fly selection or anything else possible. I think it is out of line to shame him for thinking somebody should recieve a fine for making a poor decision, especially one that apparently you can get fined for.