Flysmallie and Fishhand: 
  I may be reading the regs wrong but the special regs section on the James runs from Hooten Town to Hwy 13.  On that stretch if you want to keep black bass you can only keep 6 of which only one may be a smallie.  If you keep them, then Largemouth and Smallmouth have to be at least 15'  long.  The reg doesn't say anything about spots so I assume, and you should check with your conservation agent on this one, that the statewide 12" minimum applies.  So, before you start whacking those spots, check with your agent.    
 
As far as people keeping whatever they catch I'm afraid some folks are always going to do this.  I truly believe most people want to obey the game laws but some folks are just outlaws and never will.  One of the real problems with our game laws is, in my opinion, that not only do we not have enough agents but we also have counties in which prosecutors and judges just don't pursue these cases.  That's a touch nut to crack and can only be changed at the local level.  As far as keeping everything you catch, regs be darn, that's something that can only be changed at the personal level and you can't vote that out.  
 
It's good to hear first hand feedback about how this year's floods have changed the habitat in you home flows.  The one and only time I've fished the James the water was high, slightly murky and running fast.  Nearly all of the smallies I caught were hanging out in the crevices in the rock bottom of the river.  I don't know if that's normal for James River smallies but that was the pattern that weekedn (two years ago).  I think overall this years flood was exactly what the doctor ordered for many of our streams and rivers.  In all cases it seems to have changed up everything and we have to adjust to the new conditions.  Only time is going to tell if all of this shifting of gravel and other detrius is going to have some long term benefit for the smallie populations.   
 
Thanks for taking the time to respond to my poll.   
 
Matt