Well since Eric seems to be somewhat getting ganged up on, and I'm pretty sure I'm one of the few TN guys on an Ozark fishing forum...I'll go ahead and agree with Eric on some regards.
I will say that as a person who has fly fished/spin cast/ and used powerbait, that catching a fish of that magnitude on a fly/jig would be much more of an accomplishment to me than catching it on powerbait.
My girlfriend, who is no top-notch angler, can catch trout all day long slinging powerbait from the bank. There is quite a bit more skill involved when one has to judge depths, water clarity, wind, currents, hatches, obstruction etc. That's especially true when you fish small mountain free stone streams like we have in the Smokies (yes, I know it's an Ozark forum ha).
But I do give the guy much respect for landing the fish on 4 # test...that is by no means an easy thing to do. And that was his "catch of a lifetime," so you have to be happy for the guy.
And honestly, any style of fishing in the end accomplishes the same thing, your out by your self or with friends enjoying nature and doing what you like to do. If everyone used the same techniques, it wouldn't be nearly as interesting.