I have fished walleyes extensively on Lake of the Woods MN. and have concluded that I have caught more and larger walleyes on 4 in. Kalin Lunker Grubs in a watermelon red than any other jig/grub combination. I have lots of pumpkins and similar colors and they don't stand a chance against the watermelon red. The bad news is they don't make the Lunker Grub in watermelon red anymore. They make it in watermelon red flake which is not the same. The watermelon red had a red streak down the sides that walleyes found irresistable. I have called Kalin to see if they would make more and they said no.Their watermelon flake is just not the same. For bass fishing I have found pumpkin and watermelon red both very effective. Match the bottom of the lake to the color of the grub and you usually can't go wrong.