yea i think that you are right with your rules there. once you keep your two fish you can continue to snag for other things like suckers in the creeks and what not. i dont think if i had two paddlefish in the boat i would try to snag gar though. to risky..... and we do try to gently roll them in the boat, seth adn i... and they still beat us to death, but we don't hold thier heads, we might try that. on opening night we rolled one in the boat that racked seth lol. we probably should have held that ones head to save seth's....