I don't see the big deal with this guy keeping the fish. Chances are the fish was going to die anyway. People shouldn't get that upset with someone having to keep a fish of this size. If you were in the woods and saw a monster buck during rifle season would you just take a pic and make a replica of it or would you shoot the thing. My guess is you probably would shoot it. It is just part of being a hunter or fisherman. People should not make a huge deal of him keeping the fish.