Beginner's Set Up?

[Forsythian]

Hey guys, I am hoping to get some input on whether the following set up would be good for a beginner...

St.Croix Avid 6'6" 3pc. 4wt with an Orvis Black Battenkil Barstock II reel.

This would be for an 11 year old boy of smaller-than-average height (he takes after his mom)... thanks a bunch!

[Phil Lilley]

That's a pretty short rod... esp if you're fishing open areas. I've started people on shorter rods in the past and they usually want to, or I think they should go to a longer rod. I'd start him with at least an 8 foot rod... unless you're fishing Swan or Beaver Creeks. Then shorter is better.

I know- buy him one of each!

[Wayne SW/MO]

I'd start him with at least an 8 foot rod...

I agree, and I would also bump it up to a 5 or 6 weight. A 4 weight is a nice rod, and I have one, but it can be a Bear if there is much wind. A heavier rod would also be suitable for warm water fish if the opportunity arises.

IMO.

[jOrOb]

I started my 7 year old out on a 8ft 5 and regretted it. Finally switched to a 7'6" 4wt. He could cast it without fighting it or becoming fatigued. He is 11 now and has graduated to a 8'6" 5 wt TFO and is building A 9' 3WT.

It is possible to go too long. Think how you would feel with a 12 footer.

Also, Ryne has landed a couple fish over 7 lbs on a 4. The softer action is more forgiving to light tippets.

I say go with Ohil on the 8' but stick with the 4wt.

[Snow Fly]

My granddaugther is 10 and tall for her age, she is set up with a St. Croix Avid 8'6" 5wt. 4 piece, 5wt DT fly line and one of my older reels, Cortland LTD Graphite 60. Does a good job with it! At this time still with the roll cast and will move to the next stage when she is ready.