Fly Rod Weight Question

[CS Huntley]

I’ve never really fished anything other than a 5 weight, but my TFO was lost/ stolen during a recent move and I need a replacement. I see a closeout Sage Approach 490-4 on Amazon for $225. Seems like a good deal, but I was wondering how much different a 4 weight is going to be from the 5 weight. I mostly fish the trout parks/ rivers near them or the tail water at Taneycomo. I know I need a bigger rod for throwing streamers at night, but just looking for something to get me back onto the water. Is the 4 weight too light for the local streams and rivers?

Thanks,

Chris

[ness]

No, 4 is a really good all-around rod size. I doubt you’ll notice much of a difference. I use a 4 a lot on the creeks and at the parks. More than any other weight. Mostly dries and nymphs, but it handles small streamers fine.  If you’ve still got 5 weight line, try it on the 4. It’ll slightly slow the action. 

[CS Huntley]

I’ve still got 5 weight line so I’ll give that a shot. Appreciate the advice. 

Chris