I have already stated that I feel shuffling should be illegal. Whether or not it is enforceable is unimportant. There are laws in every area that are not enforced. Wearing a seatbelt is the law. But if I'm sitting a a stop light next to a cop, and I'm not wearing my seatbelt, is he going to pull me over. Probably not. But when I have a passenger in my vehicle that does not normaly wear a seatbelt, I do have something to say when it is the law. Right now if I see someone shuffling all I can say is that I think it is unethical, they probably don't care. I also think it's unethical to climb in a tree with a high powered rifle and wait for a deer to come strolling along minding his own business. But that's the hunter's choice not mine. I'm not so radical that I belong to PETA or protest hunting, all my fishing buddies love to hunt, I just choose not to. Now If it was illegal and I saw someone doing it, then I would have something to say.
If we are to keep this act legal, since it makes it easy for some to fish, then we need to look at legalizing some other methods of taking fish and game in the state of Missouri. First we should legalize snagging. Right now our wildlife code states that all gamefish that are not hooked in the mouth must be released to the water unharmed. I know that I would have to consider fishing bass tournaments again, especially in the sping when these fish are on the nests. Another thing we should legalize is netting. Why should these shufflers have to go to all the trouble of bring a rod and reel, all they need is a net. Kick up a few rocks, net my limit, go home. I could be in and out with my limit in just a few minutes. And for all those deer hunters out there, how about baiting. We, as a state, have found this practice so unethical that we have rules against it in the state. (Wildlife Code - CSR 10-7.431) And this is no different than what shuffling is. This is the same basis that Arkanasas has used for their shuffling law. It states on their website. "No chumming is allowed in catch-and-release areas. This is defined as “to dislodge or deposit any substance not attached to a hook which may attract fish.” Chumming in catch-and-release areas is prohibited because normal trout feeding behavior can be disrupted and the stream environment can be damaged.
One common example of chumming is tossing canned corn into the water to stimulate feeding. The technique of dislodging material from the streambed to attract trout, known as the “San Juan Shuffle,” is also considered chumming." Can I buy some of that feed at the hatchery and just use it?
I know I'm on a rant, but I will end it with this. Several years ago our own Phil Lilley published an article called "Taneycomo Shuffle, Follow-up ". In that article he quoted retired MDC person Spence Turner as saying, "If Lake Taneycomo anglers requesting shuffling regulations were honest with themselves, the reason they want to make shuffling illegal is the belief shufflers are catching more trout than they catch."
Anybody here want to agree with Spence, I don't think Phil does, and I sure won't.
Catch something big!
Ronnie