This thread started as one person asking the opinion on wether trout beads would be effective on Taney. I believe the answer is "yes".
Some how this got turned in to an ethical issue. After reading the regulations on all of Taney, there seems to be no ethical issue at all. I do not see all the bait fishermen getting hammered on here for fishing with bait in lower Taney. Thats probably because it is perfectly legal. Now I dont bait fish just because I prefer not to. That is my right just as it is others right to fish with beads if they so choose. Absolutely nothing wrong with it. I guided up in Alaska all summer and used beads almost every day. Like stated before, as a guide it is my job to use the most productive methods possible. If the client is set on catching a fish on a sinking line stripping a 6" leach, well then it is my job to do my best to make that happen. If the fish are on nothing but eggs, all I can do is recommend what I know will catch fish, but ultimately it is my job to make the client happy and help achieve his/her goals for the trip.
I have used beads on Taney and they have caught fish. I just prefer to strip mohair leaches, slump busters and soft hackles.
I usually dont fish glow balls either, but if I was facing a skunk.........I would try a bead! I know others have opinions and that is great that they have the right to share them. You probably would not like to hear my opinion about other's opinions, so I will just keep those to myself