My real opinion on the issue, if it floats, It's good enough for me. It's all good... jonboats, canoes, drift boats, hard kayaks, inflatable kayaks, and yes, even aluminum canoes. If it will float me, and my fishing gear to the holes I want to fish, that's all I need. I don't personally like anything motorized though. It just ruins the experience for me.... Paddling should be part of a float trip.