J-Doc Posted July 11, 2013 Posted July 11, 2013 SONAR INTERPRETATION - HOW TO READ MY SONAR (FISH FINDER) AND UNDERSTAND WHAT I’M LOOKING ATI'm starting this thread in hopes that it will become a "sticky" at the top of this forum. I hope this thread serves the novice sonar user and the experienced sonar user as well. First a few questions: How many of us have a fish finder? (I'm guessing 90% of us do) How many use the "fish symbols" because without that, you just don't know what you're looking at and don't have enough confidence in your graph to find fish without it? Do you turn the sensitivity down so much that it will only show "big fish" or big solid objects? Do you know what you're looking at??? (hey, I have to ask) :-) Well....... This is where I hope the "experienced" angler can teach the "inexperienced" sonar user. Where the super-sharp guys that have the really expensive equipment and vast experience can teach some of the common weekend anglers that may only have the $100 Lowrance Cuda, the $70 Humminbird, or some older fish finder their buddy gave them that’s so old, you can’t even find it on the internet. If it will show fish arches, then you can learn something here.What am I seeing on my graph?Is that a bass or is that a catfish on the bottom? Or is that a group of rocks? If you have a $2,000-$3,000 Lowrance or Humminbird unit and feel you need to learn more about sonar interpretation, this is what I hope will be the thread for you as well to cover a broad range. The things I have learned in just the last 2yrs have helped me tremendously and it's taken scratching and clawing to get the information. Why? Because I didn’t have someone to simply take a trip and show me advanced knowledge of what to look at and how to interpret it. I'm hoping this thread will "balloon" into something big and useful for all anglers. I believe others should teach and share the knowledge in order to pass it on to perpetuate the sport. Not, give away secrets in fear that they will have stiffer competition in tournaments because.........if it were easy it would be called "catching" and not "fishing". Am I right? :-) Here are a few highlights as this subject is very broad and there is already a lot of info available on the internet)FOR THE NOVICE - HOW TO READ SONAR:(If this is not you, skip forward to the next level) First…..This needs to be broken down into categories:1) Basic sonar understanding2) Advanced sonar3) Drop-shot presentation4) Side Imaging5) 360-degree imaging (I’m not covering much here as I think it’s a gimmick personally until the technology gets better) BASIC SONAR UNDERSTANDING Can't read a lot? Here is a great video http://youtu.be/KTacpPjjWiU What is a cone angle? The cone angle is how your transducer sends out a signal. The transducer sends a hi-frequency ticking sound in the shape of a cone. The signal bounces back to the transducer as it hits an object and since a fish is arch shaped in nature, it creates an arch on the graph. Why does it matter what frequency I use?What’s a frequency? (haha) Some units use 200kHz and some use up to 400 or even 800kHz. This hi-frequency, the more detailed the image presented on your graph but it also narrows the cone shape so you will cover less area. For users with structure scan or “down scan imaging”, your transducer emits in an oblong shape which is basically a “squeezed cone shape”. Look up your manual for more info on your particular unit. What’s ping speed? Ping speed is the rate of speed the transducer sends a signal. The faster the signal, the more accurate the information which is great for dropshoting (well I think so anyway) What is chart speed? Chart speed is just that, how fast the information is displayed on a chart What is Sensitivity? Should it be on auto? (typically yes) Most know this is how sensitive the unit picks up smaller signals What is noise rejection? Typically, this is rejecting electrical noise and mixed signals from aerators, trolling motors, etc. It can decrease the sensitivity I personally turn noise rejection off when I use 800kHz on my DSI unit NOW…..what is a chart?When you’re watching your fish finder, you see arches or “fish symbols” scroll across. What you’re looking at is a caption of a moment in time. Ever see a polygraph on TV? Or heart monitor on a movie when the patient flat lines and the heart stops? This is essentially what you’re seeing with your fish finder. If your unit is equipped with it, you will have lines appearing on the right hand side. What you’re seeing there is “live feed”. This is essentially the old “flasher sonar” that your grandpa or dad used back in the day. It’s vertical now instead of 360 degrees. Any of this making sense? If not, go back and re-read. J Think “chart readout” or watching a scroll of paper feeding out of a machine while it prints lines on it. That’s essentially what your graph is showing in both traditional sonar and the new structure scan or down scan. That’s the basics. Pretty easy huh? It took me forever to understand the “heart monitor” or “polygraph” thing. I had to have a guide show me on his fancy sonar while he taught me how to dropshot before I “got it”. Once I “got it”, the doors started opening. ADVANCED SONAR(This is where I need help from other forum members)So if you have structure scan or down imaging or even side scan, you probably already know what it is and how it works. Or at least the basics.When looking at structure/down scan imaging, you’re seeing a higher frequency signal sent to your unit which gives a higher definition reading. Why can’t I see fish arches with structure scan? Well, since it’s a higher frequency the signal is not as “muddy” as it is with traditional sonar so the arches are smaller. Think of it this way. When you show a split screen or when you switch from a lower frequency to a higher frequency, you will see trees show up sharper and crisper. To me, 800kHz is great for showing sunken school buses online and sunken bridges. (hahaha). These show hi-definition of the bottom structure but not as much on fish arches. Its best to get a good reading on what you’re seeing for both bottom structure, hard pan or soft, depth, brush piles, rocks, etc. as well as fish arches. That’s why units that show both traditional sonar and structure scan on split screens is the best way to learn between the two. DROPSHOT PRESENTATIONEver wanted to learn how to do this beter? I know I did. I had a local guide take me out one day and gave me a quick lesson on what I was seeing underwater and within 2mins, I “got it”. I hope this explanation helps you “get it” as well. Remember when I mentioned the bars on the right side of your graph being a “live feed”?? If not, go back up to “Now, what is a chart” section and read that again. That’s essentially dropshot presentation. You drop a bait or a jig, or even live bait below your transducer and watch the object fall “live” by watching the little lines on the right side. You’ll see your bait dropping and then you’ll see a diagonal line on your graph. THAT is the history or the readout of where your bait was as it was falling. It doesn’t mean your bait fell at an angle, it’s just a readout of the “cone angle”. (re-read cone angle above). In order to drop shot or see your bait of any kind on the graph, it MUST be within the cone angle. I suggest using the lowest frequency possible to create a “WIDE” cone angle. The deeper the water, the larger your cone will be. If you’re in 10ft, your cone diameter will be much smaller in size than it will be in 30ft. SIDE IMAGINGHere’s a good link that explains what this is and how to use it. http://youtu.be/yNucS1bniIw 360 DEGREE IMAGINGEver see a radar tower on a ship or at an airport? Ever see a radar scope on a movie where you see the plans or little “blips” on the scope in the movie TOP GUN where you can see the images projected on the scope representing the planes? Well……….that’s the same theory of 360 imaging. A transducer is lowered below the boat and scans the area up to a particular distance and projects and image. Problem is, it’s not as advanced as side imaging and structure scan so the images are a bit “blury”. If you understand what you’re looking at and how to use it, it can be a “gamechanger” as KVD says. Well, that’s a start of a very broad subject with a “simplistic” view or explanation. blacknoseddace 1 Need marine repair? Send our own forum friend "fishinwrench" a message. He will treat you like family!!! I owe fishinwrench a lot of thanks. He has been a great mechanic with lots of patience!
J-Doc Posted July 11, 2013 Author Posted July 11, 2013 Now, post your screenshots or take some photos of your sonar (fish finder) and give us some real-world examples where some experienced anglers can offer their “interpretation” and feedback on what they feel you are seeing. I will post some of my own myself for examples when I get a chance. dan hufferd 1 Need marine repair? Send our own forum friend "fishinwrench" a message. He will treat you like family!!! I owe fishinwrench a lot of thanks. He has been a great mechanic with lots of patience!
J-Doc Posted July 11, 2013 Author Posted July 11, 2013 Here is a thread I borrowed from the Beaver Lake forum. It has some good information and examples with screenshots and interpretations. This is the kind of stuff I'd ike to see gather here in this thread. Actual user photos and users asking for opinions on "what's this?" and getting feedback from other users. Need marine repair? Send our own forum friend "fishinwrench" a message. He will treat you like family!!! I owe fishinwrench a lot of thanks. He has been a great mechanic with lots of patience!
Guest Brian B. Posted July 11, 2013 Posted July 11, 2013 Thanks. For this post, I will have to re-visit it when I'm not half asleep, I do need to burn a day and really verify that I know how to properly use my gear- good post.
nathanhooper Posted July 11, 2013 Posted July 11, 2013 Here is something for discussion. I have always said, I am a visual person. lol This is how Humminbird does their DI. I believe SI is the same thing, just turned sideways. Its nice because the other day we were seeing a lot of arches, small ones, on the bottom and stacked. I could not tell if it was tree's or fish so I turned on the Humminbird. You could clearly see that it was fish not trees because the arches were reduced to little dots. It has its place, DI & SI, but for discussion sake I would take SI over DI now, as long as I got to have regular sonar also.
Bird Watcher Posted July 11, 2013 Posted July 11, 2013 Here is one I just so happened to have on my phone. I don't usually take pictures of the graph, but I did the other day to send to my buddy. Actually, this is a pretty poor representation of what the screen looked like most of the day, but it's the one I have. This is while I was sitting mostly stationary, gently bumping around with the TM. This was a school of hybrids that were suspended over a ditch adjacent to a shallower hump. You can see the thermocline forming at about 32'. most of the fish were relating at about 25-27, but these were hybrids so YMMV. When I would move over to the hump, they would be on the bottom and those were the fish that were actively feeding. Also, If you look closely you can see where my weight was making a line at about 18'. Next time I go, I'll try to get a better picture if I can find them.
J-Doc Posted July 11, 2013 Author Posted July 11, 2013 Great info! Keep it coming! Need marine repair? Send our own forum friend "fishinwrench" a message. He will treat you like family!!! I owe fishinwrench a lot of thanks. He has been a great mechanic with lots of patience!
Bird Watcher Posted July 11, 2013 Posted July 11, 2013 The one other important thing I would add would be to echo what Bill Babler said over on the Thermocline thread. I think if you leave your sensitivity on auto, you are kind of shooting yourself in the foot. I contstantly adjust my sensitivity, surface clarity, and noise rejection as conditions change. Mostly my sensitivity though.
J-Doc Posted July 11, 2013 Author Posted July 11, 2013 Here is a brief collection of some sonar photos. I've made it a habit to start collecting interesting sonar images because its very interesting to me. Plus I can go back and look at the image later in more detail and see if I missed something or get someone else's opinion on what I found. I've learned a lot from that alone. So this first image is a classic bait ball using my new Elite 5dsi with structure scan. This is using 455kHz which is the lowest frequency this unit has so it's casting a very broad oblong cone shape as described above and shown by nathanhooper (nice find by the way Nathan!). This image is showing a school of fish next to bait. The bait is the smaller "dots" grouped tightly together and the larger dots are probably white bass. Why white bass? Simply because of the time of year and the particular cove I was in at the time was known as a staging area for whites as they leave the river arm after spawning. This is a good educational image here. This image is showing a submerged tree right? Look closely at all of the multi-colored short arches/dots. That's a mess of crappie on a tree with a few larger fish near the bottom. Possibly walleye or bass? Here is a nice school of stripers and hybrids just in front of the Hwy 12 bridge on Beaver Lake. This is using traditional sonar as it gave much better "arches" than my structure scan unit. I have both units at the helm for side-by-side comparison/usage. I trolled over these rascals 5-6 times and only snagged one because they were deeper than my bait would run. They sat in this spot for hours just floating in open water (gee.........what does that tell you?) This image shows a bait school being attacked by larger fish. Probably Kentucky bass or white bass. Notice the long sweeping arch?? That's because the sonar recorded the fish at a starting depth and up and then as the fish came back down before it was not within the transducer's sounding cone (again, see sonar basics above if you don't know what the cone-shape is) So do you understand why the images show long sweeping arches now? I've seen this many times and had no clue what I was looking at. I knew it had to be a fish somehow but just didn't "get it". A little explanation makes things so much clearer doesn't it? :-) Here is a tricky image. I was using 800kHz at the time trying to get some really cool images of cedar trees. The area I was in had very large boulders mixed with cedar trees. The tree is not "floating"....it's because the cone shape is so narrow that it only picked up a portion of the tree. Does that make sense? Also, the higher frequency usage of 800kHz over 455kHz gave me a crisper image of the rock and cedar tree. It's showing an outer algae layer on the tree itself. Here's another image where I was trolling for walleye/smallmouth. I found a stump where fish were relating just past the stump. Notice structure scan doesn't show "arches" like traditional sonar. This is what I mentioned in the 1st initial post of why traditional arches differ from structure/down imaging. I can still clearly see these are fish and actively feeding. Need marine repair? Send our own forum friend "fishinwrench" a message. He will treat you like family!!! I owe fishinwrench a lot of thanks. He has been a great mechanic with lots of patience!
J-Doc Posted July 11, 2013 Author Posted July 11, 2013 The one other important thing I would add would be to echo what Bill Babler said over on the Thermocline thread. I think if you leave your sensitivity on auto, you are kind of shooting yourself in the foot. I contstantly adjust my sensitivity, surface clarity, and noise rejection as conditions change. Mostly my sensitivity though. Totally agree. I found that when I switch from 455kHz to 800kHz on my unit that I have to completely change the noise rejection, surface clarity, and contrast. Unfortunately, my unit uses Generation 1 structure scan so I do not have sensitivity settings (UGH!!!). I wish I did as it could make much better images. So thermocline...... What is it? Google it. That's an easy answer. It's the separation of water temperature. Think water and oild and how oil floats on top of water. Colder water separates from warmer water and there is a noticeable temperature change where this occurs. That's the thermocline. My unit shows a series of dashes like this..../ / / / / / / / / / and someone told me that was "noise". I disagree as I feel its picking up the thermocline change because my traditional sonar picks up similar echos and shows a thermocline on that graph as well. Need marine repair? Send our own forum friend "fishinwrench" a message. He will treat you like family!!! I owe fishinwrench a lot of thanks. He has been a great mechanic with lots of patience!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now