I used this fly this past weekend on Taneycomo and was getting hit on almost every cast at the rebar hole.
A few people on flyanglersonline.com seem to think that it is not a fly, but simply a plastic worm. My argument is, it is artificial, tied with thread. granted there are no feathers, but glo balls, san juan worms, some scuds, many "real" flies do not contain feathers. I really dont care if they do not consider this a "real" fly, it just flat out works and I will continue to use it. Just wanted to get some local feedback on the subject.