This is where I think you guys are wrong. There are too many canoe outfitters out there putting thousands of canoes on the rivers almost everyday in the summer. The floaters buy gas, food, drinks, etc. And the outfitters buy gas, pay property taxes, shuttle vehicles, land, income, employment taxes, the purchase of new canoes and rafts. That one time tax on a 20K is nothing compared to what the outfitters are paying year after year.