I haven't been to Montauk or Bennett in forever. Do they not have the daily parking pass fee? I've always just gone to Maramec since it was closest and I've never had that much trouble catching fish down there either. I'm typically not a bait fisherman, but I just felt like catching a few that way this time around for whatever reason. Most of the trout I catch come on a trout worm, rubber legged jig or a trout magnet. One thing I wish I had brought with me yesterday was the fly rod. I'm pretty sure I could have caught a few on it the way the fish were acting. Back when I was more in to trout fishing for the sport versus just getting some fish to eat, I would always have the fly rod with me.