Jigs under an indicator followed by eggs work the best for me at the Urban lakes. I fish them on the bottom. Stripping only works at night and when the wind is up a bit....otherwise forget about it. I would use Olive, Black/Yellow, or White jigs. For glo balls orange or peach has worked the best. Zebra midges work ok at times as well.
It can be tough to compete with the all the power bait guys at Carondolet and that lake gets cleaned out pretty quickly. Your best bet is Forest Park before Feb 1st. Lot's of fish, C/R, and a great group of regulars. The bucket brigrade will be out in full force this weekend (no longer C/R)...so it will be a madhouse.