When I go up north to Erie, St. Clair, or the Menominee river, tubes are king. For some reason in Missouri I've never been a big fan of tubes. I've always caught more on jigs and was a little surprised you use them over a jig. Don't quite know why, maybe the head clicks against the rocks a little more with an exposed jig head, sounding more like the clicking of a retreating crayfish.
I stole an idea from Paul Jensen called a Boutube that works pretty well up north. You tear off the tenticles from the tube and tie marabou at the end of the straight shank before the bend starts. The marabou replaces the tenticles and has a spread out action when at rest. The one good thing about a tube is there are so many ways to rig it, more than any lure I know.