i agree OTF. I think it is a great program. It is relatively close to home and I have meet a great group of guys that I have fished with over the years that I wouldn't have met without the program. It is not the same as fishing for wild trout or even fishing the current, Meramec etc, but I do look forward to it. I spend a lot of time and money driving all over the place to fish for trout and smallmouth etc. My time is not unlimited and with a 17th month old and another baby on the way the Sunday afternoon trip in the winter time is ideal for me. It is as much about enjoying the company of people I have meet as much as catching fish. I can't think of a better way to introduce my little guy to trout fishing when he gets a bit older.
I also take several winter trips to Montauk or the Meramac, which are some of my favorites of the year. I like it all as the experience is fun for me in both settings.
I am also pretty sure I read that the trout for the urban stocking program are not yet being supplied by state hatcheries (that is the long term goal, but it is not happening yet is my understanding) they are purchased from private companies.
Lastly, I still think there is too much emphasis on catch and keep trout. The trout program does have an expense, so it does seem a bit silly to have 4 fish limits on a stocked fish that cost money and time to raise. I would be ok if they stopped the Urban fishing program as long as those funds were used to purchase other trout areas and decrease the limits at trout parks and on Brown Trout, but it would need to be a give and take deal for me to be on board.