Been there. I pared things down a couple years ago, then just spent a few hours Monday doing it again. My wife laughs at me when I say I need to restock my tackle, but it is true. I'm mainly at the point where purchasing tackle is replacing things rather than buying new. I've added a few new techniques, I did go into the A-rig for winter, even though I held off and fought it for a long time. I've also been getting into deep cranking, so I've bought some fat free shads, DD-22's, and rapala DT series cranks. I'm thinking ill settle on the DT series, but I haven't made up my mind, so I do have more choices of deep cranks than I'd like. I now try to pick one style of bait, in a couple of colors, for each technique.
My system is loosely:
_________ lure- in a color for clear water, bright skies, clear water overcast, stained water bright skies, stained water overcast.
Jerk baits are megabass, 110 and 110plus, no more than 4 colors. Wiggle warts, same kind of deal. Same thing with soft plastics. The less choices the better. Jigs are pretty much 3 colors, in 3 weights for depth/fall speed control, with one of the colors for after dark.
Are there times I feel like someone might fine tune a color or something that I'm not equipped for and get on em good?
Sure.
But for me, taking away choices of baits has made me a better fisherman, because I have to work harder to find fish. If I am near fish that are going to bite, I have *something* that I can get them to eat, even if it isn't the exact *best* bait. I'll take active fish, vs a "magic" bait any day.