That is not an uncommon opinion. He has averaged over 10 wins a season. Would you be satisfied with him if he averaged 11 wins a year? Won a National Championship and played for another (got demolished but got there), does he need a National Championship every 3 rd year or every 5 th year.
You have to give him some credit for recruiting well at the very least and then acknowledge that there is only one football to go around. Guys hone their skills and bail before their senior season. IF LSU could get a Great QB, they would have won another National championship. If Saban wasn't on his historic run, I 5hinj people might look at CLM a little differently as well.
I'm happy with CLM, but we will see how long he can last in BR. The guys pulling the strings are really SPOILED by the last 10 years of success. They seem to forget that everyone plays their butt off and wants to win the Big games.