Trout eat jerkbaits. So far, I have seen them eat Rapalas (F7,F9,X-rap), LC Pointers (78's and 100's), Spro McStik's, BPS plain and XPS, Jann's Springers, and Smithwick Rogues. Basically, I haven't found a jerkbait they won't eat.
Does the McStik stand out above the crowd when fishing for trout on the White? No, not really, but throw what you like. You're not all that likely to lose one if you have good line and the ability to tie a decent knot.