I have been waiting for this discussion. Can't wait for the pros to weigh in. As a rookie.....I love Eakins/Jewel jigs. I have used a bunch, but I always go back to them. I have actually set the hook and reeled in a rock with their jigs. I do like the Chomper's jigs too. Another great jig is the Hawg Stump lure jig. I think he is out of LOZ somewhere.
As far as hook setting.....it depends on the fish. Sometimes they take it and go, sometimes they suck it in, sometimes they seem to nibble on it and I try to time the pop on their nibble.
I love the jig. I think it is the most versatile awesome lure made. You can swim it, drag it, hop it, verticle jig it......almost anything. It is easy to have a kid use too.
E.P., please tell Troy and the crew they have to owe me a commision by now! Almost everyone that fishes with me ends up a fan of the Eakins jig.