I'm not interested in fighting either so I'll acknowledge upfront that we aren't likely to find common ground on this. I'm good with that and sounds like you are, too. So we are way ahead of where other contentious topics tend to go around here.
The general feeling about it among those who dislike it in tournaments --- and yes, I am one --- is that it stretches the traditional limits of sportsmanship and that it tends to make "heroes out of zeroes." For example, what is to keep one from tossing the rig up near one bank of a big pocket or small creek, then "strolling" across to the other side on the TM with the spool disengaged, then retrieving the darn thing 150 yards or more across that pocket/creek channel? In essence, isn't that the same as trolling?
But more of an issue among us "old timers" is that the rig tends to level the playing field where skill is concerned. No one can deny that some who rarely do well in derbies (but always show up to donate ) started inhabiting the check line when the rig first came out. Yes, the fish seem to be becoming more conditioned to it these days so it isn't the "magic bullet" that it was at first, but still there are times when folks who otherwise can't catch a fish from a mud puddle with a throw net bring in a big sack and either finish high or win. Any other time of year, these same guys are consistently empty-handed at weigh-ins.
I'm not saying there is NO skill involved ... not at all. The better fishermen still win most of the time, or at least those who throw the A-rig, because no matter what you throw, you still have to find the fish, and that will always separate the haves from the have-nots. But the importance of the actual act of presenting the lure is lessened considerably with the rig, IN MY OPINION.
That's my feelings in a nutshell. Not saying they are all grounded in concrete facts. As stated in the beginning, you also have yours and you are most welcome to have them and to state them. This is a public internet forum and civilized, intelligent discussion is what these places are all about. Besides, we're talking about fishing here --- not world conflict --- and as long as we're all taking care of the resources, there isn't really a lot to get upset about.