Poaching Case

[Phil Lilley]

Court sentencings finalize one of state’s largest-ever poaching investigations

Southwest Missouri family has violations in multiple states and Canada

SPRINGFIELD, Mo. – A Greene County man’s court sentencings in December in Barton and Lawrence Counties are the most recent events in what is one of Missouri’s largest conservation cases involving the illegal taking of deer.

On Dec. 13, David Berry Jr. of Brookline, received a 120-day sentence in Barton County Circuit Court for a felony firearms probation violation. On Dec. 6, he received a one-year jail sentence in Lawrence County Associate Court after pleading guilty to taking wildlife illegally on Oct. 11. The 120-day sentence Berry Jr. received in Barton County Circuit Court will be served in addition to the one-year sentence he received in Lawrence County. These convictions were made with information obtained from Operation Game Thief, a hotline sponsored by the Missouri Department of Conservation (MDC) and the Conservation Federation of Missouri. Berry Jr.’s convictions are the tip of a long list of illegal fish and game activity by him and other members of his family.

 “It is unknown how many deer the main group of suspects has taken illegally over the past several years,” Lawrence County Conservation Agent Andy Barnes said. “It would be safe to say that several hundred deer were taken illegally.”

Lawrence County Prosecuting Attorney Don Trotter agreed.

“Conservation investigators estimated that the group was responsible for killing hundreds of deer over a three-year period,” he said. “The deer were trophy bucks taken illegally, mostly at night, for their heads, leaving the bodies of the deer to waste.”

What Barnes and Trotter were referring to were facts uncovered by several years of investigative work. On July 11, 2016, approximately 100 state, federal and Canadian wildlife officers simultaneously interviewed multiple suspects and other persons of interest in Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska, and Canada. Information gained from these and earlier interviews tied 14 Missouri residents to over 230 charges that occurred in 11 Missouri counties. Three suspects were tied to additional wildlife violations in Kansas, Nebraska and Canada. Two suspects were tied to Federal Lacey Act Wildlife violations that occurred in Kansas, Nebraska, and Canada.

As part of this effort, MDC agents concluded an 8½ month investigation by serving arrest warrants on David Berry, Jr., David Berry, Sr., currently residing in Springfield, and Kyle Berry, Everton, on Aug. 31, 2016. Other individuals in Missouri also received summonses to appear in court on charges stemming from this investigation. Charges were filed in Lawrence, Linn, Shannon, Dade, Greene, Putnam, Harrison, DeKalb, Barton, Vernon and Benton Counties. Most of the Missouri violations were related to the illegal taking of deer. Most of the deer were trophy-class animals. In many instances, only the heads and antlers were removed. More than 300 charges were filed on this group in state, federal and international jurisdictions.

Prior to the July, 2016 interviews, David Berry, Sr. and Eric Berry, 20, Everton, were convicted of taking gamefish by hand in Dade County. During the 2017 firearms deer season, while awaiting his court appearance for violations from the 2016 investigation, Eric Berry and an accomplice were caught spotlighting in Lawrence County.

To date, this group of poachers has paid $151,000 in bonds and $51,000 in fines and court costs and collectively served 33 days in jail. David Berry Sr. and David Berry Jr. had hunting, fishing and trapping privileges revoked for life by the Missouri Conservation Commission. Eric Berry and Kyle Berry had hunting and fishing privileges revoked for 18 years and 8 years respectively. Jerimiah Cline, Republic, who took wildlife illegally and assisted the Berrys, had hunting privileges revoked for five years.

Information received this fall through Operation Game Thief led to the arrests of David Berry Sr. and David Berry Jr. for violating terms of their probation. David Berry Sr. has posted bond and is awaiting a probation revocation.

People observing wildlife violations can report them through the Operation Game Thief Hotline, 1-800-392-1111 or call the local conservation agent.

---

Southwest Missouri family faces many conservation violations in multiple states and Canada.

Francis Skalicky Media Specialist 417-895-6881 x1641 Francis.Skalicky@mdc.mo.gov

[fishinwrench]

Makes me wonder what kinda gig they were into that made whitetail antlers so valuable to them.    Making knives, selling to knife makers, or something?  

Because they were into it bigtime.

They still didn't hit them as hard as they hit that one guy that sold some spoonbill eggs.  They flat ruined that ol'boys life forever.

[tjm]

current antler prices                                                       August 2018

Whitetail Grade A - $10 a pound*                      Whitetail Grade A- $11.50 a pound*
Whitetail Grade B -$6 a pound*                         Whitetail Grade B- $6 a pound*
Whitetail Grade C - $2 a pound*                        Whitetail Grade C- $2 a pound*

Since they were targeting just trophy bucks and hauling into Canada, I suspect  a taxidermy gig. One big market is in Chinese medicine. The lesser quality go into dog chews at $20 for a 6" piece, check Amazon.  I know a guy from Ne. that buys antler in 6-10 states every year,  He has told me they run about $6/lb average tailgate price.

[fishinwrench]

13 minutes ago, tjm said:

current antler prices                                                       August 2018

Whitetail Grade A - $10 a pound*                      Whitetail Grade A- $11.50 a pound*
Whitetail Grade B -$6 a pound*                         Whitetail Grade B- $6 a pound*
Whitetail Grade C - $2 a pound*                        Whitetail Grade C- $2 a pound*

Since they were targeting just trophy bucks and hauling into Canada, I suspect  a taxidermy gig. One big market is in Chinese medicine. The lesser quality go into dog chews at $20 for a 6" piece, check Amazon.  I know a guy from Ne. that buys antler in 6-10 states every year,  He has told me they run about $6/lb average tailgate price.

That's far from "lucrative".   Those guys aren't broke hillbillies by a long shot.  

The authorities knew they had money and owned lots of stuff or they'd have never worked that hard to bust them.   I can't imagine the driving force that kept them doing it.   Something doesn't smell right here, my BS meter is bouncing all over the place. 

Will have to follow the court dockets and see where this goes.

[fishinwrench]

3 hours ago, Phil Lilley said:

During the 2017 firearms deer season, while awaiting his court appearance for violations from the 2016 investigation, Eric Berry and an accomplice were caught spotlighting in Lawrence County.

A set-up?   Otherwise why not name (and charge) the accomplice ? 

[tjm]

Yes they were risking big so they had to be getting big bucks- I don't think it was $40+/lb for dog chews. But the multi year thing and the number of people involved makes me think of taxidermy, shoulder mounts can sell for hundreds or thousands. Just speculation on my part tho. If taking the antler for the China or dog market they would not "cut off the heads" and transport that mess, they would scalp them with an ax and get out.

7 minutes ago, fishinwrench said:

A set-up?   Otherwise why not name (and charge) the accomplice ? 

Under age is a possibility.  14 people charged with 230  charges, it's possible they are just naming the ones currently in court.

[fishinwrench]

3 minutes ago, tjm said:

Under age is a possibility.  14 people charged with 230  charges, it's possible they are just naming the ones currently in court

Good point.  

[tjm]

I heard that Andy just got "Game Warden of the Year"

Quote

Lawrence County Conservation Agent Andy Barnes on being named the Southeastern Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies 2018 Wildlife Officer of the Year;

 

[tjm]

You must know the guy!

^^ changed that big laugh on my last post ^^^ to a lovin heart, eh

[fishinwrench]

12 minutes ago, tjm said:

You must know the guy!

Me?  Noway.  I just know that in big stings like that there is always a hidden agenda, and a story within the story that never gets reported.....and I find stuff like that interesting.  😊

No mention of property seizure? 

Plus the sentence on "felon in possession of a firearm" seems incredibly light.