Oh Chiefy, I'm 55 years old and have owned fishing poles for 51 of them. I've caught carp on spincast gear, spinning gear, baitcasting gear, fly rods, trotlines, limb lines.... and I wanna say jugs too... but that might not be true.
Gar pull like hell too, and they even jump sometimes, but inspite of what appears to be "excitement" I'm just not into persuing them purposely.
I will, however, stand on the bank with a beer while YOU catch them, and tell you what you're doing wrong. 😊