I kind of fall on the other side of the fence about the old baits being that much better. I know some very good Wiggle Wart fishermen who say there isn't a dime's difference in the old and the newest ones. Granted, there were some made around the Rapala transition time that just plain sucked, but my sources tell me the new Original Series baits will catch em just the same as the pre-Rap ones.
As long as I'm hearing that from the caliber of Wiggle Wart winders that I'm referring to, you boys can duke it out over the pre-Rap ones without me.
Gotta say, too, that my feelilngs are influenced by the fact that I'm usually throwing something else when the water temp hits that 50-degree mark. I've had some good days on a Wart and feel that I'm a fair hand with it, but I'm much better with another early-spring tactic.