I think if you look around at those that have an issue with this you will understand that they DO help out. It's not about not helping the members here, it's about not helping people that are just cruising the internet looking for the good spots. If you don't think it happens then you are nuts. It happens a lot more than what you realize.
I really don't care, I don't fish that area. But you have to realize what this does to the fishery. Those smallmouth are going to come from miles away to winter in that area. So it's not just the pressure on the fish in that hole, it's affecting a huge population. And to think that 100% of those fish make it back without harm is a beautiful dream, but it's not happening.
I have given detailed information to many on here. I've given up spots that most people would never find in a million years. But I did it through a PM that didn't put that information out there for everyone to find. It wouldn't be fair to the resource.
Like I said, I really don't care. I have never fished there and probably never will. But don't get all upset when someday somebody gives up one of your "secret" locations.