My dad lived on The Hill when he moved to St Louis and lived next door the Amighetties. I'm old school or maybe it's what we had all the time so that's what I prefer. I've eaten at every restaurant on the Hill but I like Cunetto's and Rigazzi's. Gitto's for high priced food.
We do Thanksgiving a little different. Bread from Amighetties, Italian lunch meat and imported soft gorgonzola from Volpi, toasted ravs from Gitto's and baked goods from Missouri Bakery.
Cold beer and good red wine and you're set. This is the menu we used to take to Bennett on opening weekend of C n R. But I haven't there since my folks died.