bry, dont take it wrong. Some of these guys spend days upon days on the water and if they havent run into it, then sometimes its hard to believe. Being they have seen shad do it, then it was an honest question. I thought that also when I first read it. We all hear stories from people that think they know and really they dont have a clue about the situation they are seeing. Was fishing the other day and a gentleman was telling me about fish boiling in a back of the next cove. Went over to see about catching some "easy" fish. Only thing I saw was large gizzard shad flipping on the surface once in awhile. Nothing chasing them, just their normal routine. Thought I had missed them. The gentlemen came back around and said, "Look at all those fish boiling, they are sure tearing it up." In his mind he was right, and not to argue I just left it alone.
I know I run into this often, and Im sure the better guys on here run into it more than I do. Dont feel bad, keep posting.