My dad and his buddy Vince fished the streams around here. They would almost always used a black Zoom Trick Worm on a slider head. I fished with my dad once on Big Sugar when I was down here for Thanksgiving maybe close to 30 years ago. We fished Trick worms that day and did fairly well as I remember. We fished upstream, wet wading, to me, coming down from Washington, it was a little chilly, but I think my poor dad about froze to death.
We'd throw that worm into likely cover, behind a stump, log or rock, and usually they'd hit it right away. If no bite, swim it back with the current and every once in a while, one would grab it when it was swimming.
Another plastic the folks that fish the local streams use is a Zoom Tiny Brush Hog. The smaller Zoom Lizards are popular too.
When I was stationed in Maryland, I fished the Potomac near Harpers Ferry. The river there is about a mile wide, but lots of rocky shallows with lots of place to wade. I always used Rooster Tails there. You could catch 30-50 smallies on a good day, but you'd be lucky to have one that went over 14 inches.
I need to find some wading spots around here and do a little more stream fishing. It's fun catching those smallies in current.