Middle meramec report

[fishinwrench]

8 minutes ago, Chief Grey Bear said:

 

There is no other way to interpret it.

Well am I wrong ?    Who, that YOU consider a knowledgeable fishermen, has changed their mind about this ?   

I mean, your beloved MDC and their team of wicked smart biologists even want them gone....Do they not?  Otherwise why the regs designed to thin them out considerably ?   

I think you just like to disagree with me as much as humanly possible.   

[Mitch f]

Would it be ok to throw Asian carp up on the bank??

[Chief Grey Bear]

I don't think you even understand what you say.

What you said was that Spots need to be eradicated and that no one with any real world experience on the river would think differently. So you just discredited anyone that doesn't subscribe to your rationale. 

 What makes you the authoritative expert? What makes you the real world ambassador of river fishing?

[Flysmallie]

26 minutes ago, Mitch f said:

Would it be ok to throw Asian carp up on the bank??

I don't know what the law says but surely there's a better use for them than that? Do the Asian's not like their carp? Not trying to be a smartass I just really don't know. 

[fishinwrench]

Chief,

You answer my question, then I'll answer yours.   

Again.....Am I wrong ?

[Chief Grey Bear]

40 minutes ago, fishinwrench said:

Well am I wrong ?    Who, that YOU consider a knowledgeable fishermen, has changed their mind about this ?   

I mean, your beloved MDC and their team of wicked smart biologists even want them gone....Do they not?  Otherwise why the regs designed to thin them out considerably ?   

I think you just like to disagree with me as much as humanly possible.   

Quite the editing. 

The wicked smart biologist at the MDC, as well as a few of us without an iota of real world river experience, know that the Spots are there to stay. You might as well get used to it. The enhanced regs are just to make you feel all giddy and googly inside that you are making a difference. 

But hey, there are still thousands of miles of rivers in the state that don't have any! Explore a little my world traveler!

I don't like to disagree with you at all. You just make it impossible not too.

[Chief Grey Bear]

2 minutes ago, Flysmallie said:

I don't know what the law says but surely there's a better use for them than that? Do the Asian's not like their carp? Not trying to be a smartass I just really don't know. 

It's non-native so there are no regs for them. You can do what you want the Wonton rule does not apply.

[fishinwrench]

So wrong yes, or wrong no ?

And I didn't edit, I just added more.

[Mitch f]

3 minutes ago, Flysmallie said:

I don't know what the law says but surely there's a better use for them than that? Do the Asian's not like their carp? Not trying to be a smartass I just really don't know. 

I think they prefer regular carp. My father in law once had an Asian Carp from the Mississippi. I told him to bleed it and remove the dark meat. He didn't listen.....he never ate one again! Yuck ? 

[Chief Grey Bear]

4 minutes ago, fishinwrench said:

Chief,

You answer my question, then I'll answer yours.   

Again.....Am I wrong ?

Remind me what your question was.