I've had really good success with the Spro BBZ-1 Rat. I throw it at night a bunch and also early in the morning around bushes. When they hit it it's like they're trying to kill it. I wouldn't mess with anything other than the biggest one either. I know several guys do really well on a Bull Shad like Dave was talking about. After yesterday, I'm a believer in the fact that it would work. I have one and have never thrown it, but I saw a ton of large gizzard shad yesterday up the James. I have two large bait setups. 1 is a Dobyns Fury 795 swimbait/umbrella rig rod with a Lew's Super Duty Wide Spool. I throw 25ld Big Game mono on that. My other one is an Okuma Guide Select. Same reel, 65lb braid. Hope that helps at least a little. I swear by that rat though.