I think our impoundments hold there own against most states as far as size. I did say most. Dont you think smaller creeks just have smaller fish? I know in our area I can fish Center creek and catch some respectable smallmouth 12- 18 inches. If I fish Jones Creek a tributary of Center the size goes way down. Its a smaller and shallower creek but has colder water. I am sure others will have a differant slant on it. Now here is a big smallie!
World Record Smallmouth Bass
Weight: 11 pounds, 15 ounces.
Angler: David Hays
Date: July 8 / 1955
Location: Dale Hallow Lake, Kentucky
Length: 27 inches
Girth: 21.66 inches
As usual, there is controversy. Raymond Barlow, whoever the hell he is, submitted an affidavit to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers stating that Hayes' fish had only weighed 8 lb 15 oz and that he had stuffed three pounds of metal in the fishes' mouth and stomach to make it a record.
Most records that pre-date the 70s are not accurate. Fish were not properly weighed or documented. Over-excited fisherman often added 30% to the size and weight of a fish. Many records that have been submitted are of people that catch fish and then let the story grow for a few years before entering.
In this case, if you input the dimensions into a bass weight calculator , it shows the fish should weigh close to what David's claims are. David Hays does have the World Record Smallmouth Bass, which is backed by an investigation by the IGFA.