For the deal I described, I use 3-4" creek baits (shiners, chubs, whatever I can catch) lip-hooked on a heavy-hooked 1/4oz maribou jig. 2 rigs straight down from the boat and a couple more cast out with slip bobbers set 4-5' off the bottom. Bait shop bass minnows would probably work too. That rig catches both species fine. If you know the stripers are passing thru, they'll rise to a topwater, but you won't likely see them break otherwise.
What's weird is that it doesn't seem that the blues follow the stripers all the way to the back end for the twilight feasts. For that deal I bank fish the twilight hours in the back end with fresh, cut shad that I net right there just before dark. They won't touch day-old or frozen shad. The stripers show up there just after dark, and it can be fast & furious for an hour or 2. If you can't see or catch a few big gizzards there first, you're in the wrong place or the wrong time. If you try it in a boat you'll spook them out. That's how I stumbled on the deal, I was throw-netting shad from the boat in a few feet of water and saw the giant dark streaks as they scooted away to safety. Many, many experiments later, I've settled on the 2 methods I mentioned here. Did it for 10 years straight. It flat works.
If you're gonna try Beaver with Quill I'll even give you my best spot. I've never offered that to anyone...